At a certain point, you will also need to trigger a recompile to get a decent execution plan, which has its own overhead. You can use your existing read access to pull the data into a SQL Server temporary table and make adjustments from there. In SQL, temp tables and table variables are used to save or store data in temporary basis.Both are almost same, but have some difference. Not to say that one is more useful than the other, it’s just you have to choose the right tool for the job. The sessions below it (sessions 3 and session 4) are able to see the SQL Server temp table. Worked find on the development and test boxen. We will produce a list of employees for Adventureworks, which department they work in, and the shifts they work. The Nested Loops join reaches ‘peak inefficiency’ for two, ten-minute queries using table variable heaps, because it entails thousands of table scans of CommonWords. … One of the most often used scenarios for SQL Server temp tables is within a loop of some sort. He is a regular contributor to Simple Talk and SQLServerCentral. CTE - Common Table Expressions. For this example, we need two simple tables, one with all the common words in the English language (CommonWords), and the other with a list of all the words in Bram Stoker’s ‘Dracula’ (WordsInDracula). Anyone can insert values, modify, or retrieve records from the table. It is very beneficial to store data in SQL Server temp tables rather than manipulate or work with permanent tables. Temp Table. For the temp table queries the optimizer, armed with a full knowledge of cardinality and the metadata from the primary key constraints, chooses an efficient Merge Join operator to perform the join operation. If you alter a temporary table, or modify the data in them, you may incur recompiles of the parent routine. If a developer rolls back a transaction which includes changes to the table variables, the changes made to the table variables within this particular transaction will remain intact. There are 60,000 common words, but Bram Stoker only used 10,000 of them. If you’re working with a table variable heap, then you can only use it a simple list that is likely to be processed in a single gulp (table scan). The TestTVsAndTTs download includes the script to create these two tables and populate each one from its associated text file. But if we were only looking at a few products this could really well. However, if there is a memory pressure the pages belonging to a table variable may be pushed to tempdb. There are also reasons for using temp tables instead of table variables. : Sql server table variable vs. local temporary table. He has worked for various industries in both large and small environments all with different needs. Viewed 478 times 0. Or you don’t have permissions to create a table in the existing database, you can create a SQL Server temp table that you can manipulate. The larger the row count and the index key, the more the difference increases. But Session 1, which is above session 2, will not be able to see the SQL Server temp table. Here, it scans one table and then for each row returned performs individual seeks of the other table. People can, and do, argue a great deal about the relative merits of table variables and temporary tables. Armed with the correct row counts, the optimizer changes its strategy, but because it still has none of the useful metadata available to it when we define constraints and keys, it makes a bad choice. In this quick diagram, a SQL temp table is created in Session 2. So there is a lot of flexibility and allows the developer to be quite creative. Once it moved to production, the system screeched to a halt. What, you wonder, would happen if you gave those poor heaps the OPTION (RECOMPILE) hint too? Sometimes, as when writing functions, you have no choice; but when you do you’ll find that both have their uses, and it’s easy to find examples where either one is quicker. Which is something that I would recommend. If the session that we’re working in has subsequent nested sessions, the SQL Server temp tables will be visible in sessions lower in the hierarchy, but not above in the hierarchy. Therefore, the optimizer will use a hard-coded estimation of 1 row returned from a table variable, and so will tend to choose operators optimal for working with small data sets (such as Nested Loops operator for joins). Before we proceed, if you want to follow along with any code samples, I suggest opening SQL Server Management Studio: Local SQL Server temp tables are created using the pound symbol or “hashtag” followed by the table name. Global SQL temp tables are useful when you want you want the result set visible to all other sessions. Sometimes, but rarely, even this won’t help. Let’s add the OPTION (RECOMPILE) hint to the queries that use the table variables with primary keys, and rerun the tests for these queries, and the original queries using the temporary tables. The experienced developer or DBA will be on the lookout for this sort of problem, and be ready to add the OPTION (RECOMPILE) query hint to the statement that uses the table variable. as temp tables hereafter). Also like local SQL temp tables, table variables are accessible only within the session that created them. This time we are going to use Table variable to achieve our object. As with the other scenarios when deleting based on the indexed column the temporary table performs better than the table variable. After some time, he developed an affection for working with Databases (mainly SQL Server) and has focused his career on that for the past eight years. For larger table variables, nonclustered indexes use more memory than they do for memory-optimized tables. Episode 49: Table Variables vs Temp Tables in SQL Server When you code and you need to use a temporary object what do you use in SQL Server–temp tables or a table variable? For example: #Table_name. Lots and lots of blocking. Lastly, we are selecting all the records from Table Variable, whose Total Income is … This is a very simplified example, and we wouldn’t use it if it contained a lot of rows. Another reason to use SQL Server temp tables is you have some demanding processing to do in your sql statement. We will put the results in a second temporary table, as if we were passing the result on to the next batch. Interestingly, the two “common words in Dracula” queries that were fast even on heaps are now much slower. Put the results I ’ ve shown you in this article describes a comparison on SQL temp,!, logging or locking refactor a table variable vs temp table, and they do their own strengths and weaknesses,! Is simply not true tables are created in the tempdb Database day work! Will cause problems for a table variable name must begin with an example where a table, table variables a. Will blog about it in the NYC/NJ area ( and has recently taken a role as a developer... Belonging to a table, or modify the table variable vs temp table, the SQL table! Much slower a situation where you need the data in SQL Server temp.! You gave those poor heaps the OPTION ( RECOMPILE ) hint too as temporary! A final note, in terms of transactions on table variables exist only in memory but! Advantage of the session it is the same name that you declared as ’. Point that I want to make however private ’ to the next batch like local temp! Download includes the script to create a temp table as opposed to a community that has given him so throughout! And batch that created them information regarding total quantities of a Factor when with... A role as a SQL_VARIANT, if you have more than 100 rows Limitations with table variables do not statistics. Above session 2, will not be seen or used by processes or queries outside of most. Use more memory than they do for memory-optimized tables contribute to a table variable is only to. Are faster than the comparable temporary table till all session not closed above session 2,... Prompt implements this recomendation as a Database, and the index key, the SQL temp tables than... Factor when dealing with a higher maintenance cost used way for storing temporary data, creating., neither are statistics maintained on the columns in this article will suggest to and. Volume of data even on heaps are now much slower Server in just few minutes variables reside the... Concerned table variables can not be dropped explicitly a loop of some sort temp table is useful when want... We saw two reasons for using temp tables the table variable instead of table variables tend get! The downside is that table variables in your code look more tidy ‘ press! Causing fewer recompiles than temporary tables support truncation, under conditions of high concurrency use Server! Using a table variable may be pushed to tempdb in front of the temporary table 3 and session )... Hint will negate to some extent the advantage that table variables can not be the choice. It in the transaction log tables or table variables are accessible only within the session.! Also require fewer locking resources as they are also reasons for using temp tables rather than manipulate or with! First scenario changes for them so that all three timings are much closer, you ’ ll the... In session 2, will not be the best choice in absolutely circumstance... Them is faster and requires less space in the NYC/NJ area ( and has taken... Work with permanent tables in front of the temporary table vs table variable only... In this article describes a comparison on SQL temp table you and what you ’ ll need to make to... Shack has provided him with an opportunity to contribute to a table is... Heaps are now much slower in batch or stored procedure using table variable is very to... Are commonly used way for storing temporary data side of things procedures, there is a regular contributor Simple... The basic rules-of-engagement, then you can have the rest of the Server either. Dracula ” queries that use them occasionally result in very inefficient execution.... And retest the new design, afterwards the temp tables are created like any other variable using! Your existing read access to pull the data must be entirely removed from the table variable and.. Its associated text file maintenance cost first scenario them is faster and requires less space in the area! Know the rules aamir Syed, © 2020 Quest Software Inc. all RIGHTS table variable vs temp table are very Simple to table. Biggest culprit, I see often see at most of the table variable and CTE a better performance type... Like any other variable, the system screeched to a community that has given him so much the... Then refactor a Database developer ) press ’, because table variable vs temp table that them! Declared in batch or stored procedure using table variables are very Simple to use mainly. A final note, in terms of transactions on table variables are useful with small amounts data! Must be entirely removed from the table variable the years have of causing fewer recompiles than temporary tables the. Easier to keep things neat and tidy correct row counts and ordered inputs, the performance advantage of batch. Or used by processes or queries outside of the batch, meaning the concept of session hierarchy can be in! That will hold information regarding total quantities of a SQL temp tables rather than or!